The Harvard College Democrats
(shield)
(shield)

6214
DOORS

1732
CALLS

User login

Syndicate

Syndicate content

McCain Blooper Reel: A Matter of History

Posted on Wed, 07/23/2008 - 4:49pm by Eva Lam

It should go without saying that John McCain is leaning very, very heavily on Iraq, and particularly the effectiveness of the surge, in order to make his case that he would be a superior Commander-in-Chief to Barack Obama. In case you haven't been following the most recent round of sniping between Obama and McCain, it goes roughly like this:

McCAIN. First there was the surge, then there was stability. Surge good!
OBAMA. Right, but the stated purpose of the surge was to make space for a political reconciliation, which didn't happen. Surge bad!
McCAIN. But other awesome stuff happened after the surge too, like the Anbar Awakening. Surge good!

(See, I told you it would be rough.)

Then, unfortunately, the facts got in the way. It seems that the Anbar Awakening (or Sunni Awakening, or Iraqi Awakening; whichever term you prefer, it refers to the establishment of a number of councils of Sunnis who cooperated with the American military against Sunni insurgents) actually happened before the surge. TPM strings it all together:

As McCain might say: "I mean, that's just a matter of history."

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

And CBS edited the video

Posted on Thu, 07/24/2008 - 8:27am by Elise Liu

And CBS edited the video footage of McCain's error in the interview, substituting a different answer altogether. So much for the liberal media...

Yes, yes - I meant to

Posted on Thu, 07/24/2008 - 9:03am by Eva Lam

Yes, yes - I meant to mention this in the post, and I'm glad you put it in the links sidebar - but definitely read the coverup coverage. I don't know precisely what CBS' justification was for leaving the blooper out of the interview, but they did post it online. I'm almost inclined to think that it's a good thing, since plenty of folks might well believe McCain's misstatement if it were aired without someone pointing out the historical inaccuracy - but I guess that's all speculation.